Whenever a freaky new product debuts, you better believe consumers review the sh*t out of it, posting to Twitter, Facebook, Reddit—you name it, the comments are there and they're REAL. But the criticism gets gets out of control when the effects of said foodstuff is, um, adverse. Like that time Burger King served black bun burgers and customers experienced odd trips to the bathroom.

So it only makes sense that the disconcertingly bright pink Peeps Oreos are receiving backlash online for their insane food dye. Most users are taking to Twitter to complain about their tongue and mouths turning hot pink and staying that way—even after brushing and going to bed. Awkward.

Some people honestly didn't like the taste but had no pink-dye problems.

xView full post on X

Others experienced highlighter mouth.

But then the claims got even weirder.

The lesson here is to eat unnaturally colored foods at your own risk. Kapeesh?

Follow Delish on Instagram.