It was innocent—all we wanted to know was how you take your coffee. But we started a creamer vs. coffee war that none of us could've expected.
It was pure coffee lover's bliss in the beginning—until a wave of people started voting for A1 (aka the cup that is entirely, 100 percent creamer, people), and which led others to have some serious QUESTIONS:
Which now begs the question:
And also:
Ok, and finally:
Also, a special shoutout to all fans who thought this was makeup instead of coffee. We love you, still.
![ina garten and jeffrey](https://hips.hearstapps.com/hmg-prod/images/jeffrey-garten-and-ina-garten-attend-the-barefoot-under-the-news-photo-1713807458.jpg?crop=1.00xw:0.668xh;0,0&resize=360:* "2011 "Barefoot Under The Stars" Benefit")
